Friend & Family Owned - Trade-in and SAVE

13.5" to 17" Circle Y Josey-Mitchell Renegade Hustler Barrel Saddle MJ54

13.5" to 17" Circle Y Josey-Mitchell Renegade Hustler Barrel Saddle MJ54

Product Details

13.5" to 17" Circle Y Josey-Mitchell Renegade Hustler Barrel Saddle MJ54
13.5" to 17" Circle Y Josey-Mitchell Renegade Hustler Barrel Saddle MJ54
13.5" to 17" Circle Y Josey-Mitchell Renegade Hustler Barrel Saddle MJ54
13.5" to 17" Circle Y Josey-Mitchell Renegade Hustler Barrel Saddle MJ54
Circle Y Price Match

Josey-Mitchell Renegade Hustler Barrel Saddle MJ54

Made In The USA

The Josey-Mitchell Renegade Hustler is a barrel racing saddle designed for riders seeking a secure and balanced position during aggressive runs. Constructed with deep chestnut leather and hand-tooled arrow weave basket accents, it features a wide swell and tall cantle to keep riders in an ideal position. The roughout hardseat and 3-way rigging make it suitable for riders who prefer a ranchy look and need different rigging capabilities for multiple horses. The saddle, curated by barrel racing pro Ty Mitchell, also offers Circle Y’s custom Copper Aztec conchos and the Ultimate DURAhide tree in regular and wide sizes.

The saddle's 3-way rigging eliminates the need for a rear cinch by distributing rigging pressure over a greater area on the horse's back. Additionally, the saddle is designed to aid in achieving better balance and horsemanship, ultimately improving run times for barrel racers. The 3-Way Adjustable In-Skirt rigging allows for easy changes in rigging position, and the placement of the saddle on the horse's back is emphasized for comfort and function. Circle Y also provides guidance on saddle fit, advising against over-padding and offering correctional pads for horses with specific topline conformation issues.

In summary, the Josey-Mitchell Renegade Hustler is an ideal saddle for barrel racers seeking a secure and balanced position during aggressive runs. It offers a unique combination of features, including a wide swell, tall cantle, roughout hardseat, and 3-way rigging for different rigging capabilities. Additionally, the saddle's design, curated by barrel racing pro Ty Mitchell, emphasizes balance, horsemanship, and improved run times. Circle Y provides detailed guidance on rigging, saddle placement, and saddle fit, aiming to ensure the comfort and performance of both horse and rider.


  • Color: Chestnut
  • Hardware: Copper Aztec
  • Swell Width: 13"
  • Cantle Height:4 1/2"
  • Horn Size: 4" Tall, 2" Cap
  • Skirt Size: 13 1/2" x 23"
  • Other Upgrades: 3-Way Adjustable In-Skirt Rigging; Rider Locking Buckle; Forward Swing Fenders

Western Saddle Seat Size Calculator

Please try our new seat sizing tool to find your size

Calculated Seat Size Shown Below

Please select your body shape:

Do you prefer a tighter Barrel Fit?

Are you fitting for a Tucker Saddle?

Calculated Seat Size:

There is a lot of room for personal preference with seat sizing, but as a general rule it is better to error on the side of ordering a seat size that is too large rather than erring on the side of a seat that will be too small.

Things to Consider

  • Tucker adds 1/2inch to their seat sizes (due to thick seat padding)
    16.5” Tucker = 16” normally

  • Barrel riders usually take 1” less on the seat size
    16” Trail Rider = 15” Barrel Rider

  • Ranch (slick seats) usually ride smaller (1/2inch seat size) so they don’t slide around
    16” is for most men, 15” for most women

  • Trail Saddles with High Cantles (5”) make the seat sizes feel smaller
    Trail Saddle with 5” cantle will feel smaller in the seat than one with a 3.5” cantle

  • English Saddles don’t convert exactly but often are 2” bigger
    18” English = 16” Western

  • Riders with inseams under 30” or 5’ tall and under often need custom cut fenders
    Tall riders with long legs but lighter weight may need custom cut fenders as well

Checking the Fit

  • General Guideline is about 3 fingers between your thigh and the swell.

Similar Products

This Item Qualifies for Free Shipping
Seat / Size
Tree / Size
Trade in for a discount?
Laurie Cancemi from Facebook

I've purchased 2 saddles from the Horse Saddle Shop. Both times it was a pleasure. The first saddle was not custom and was an easy transaction. The second time, I ordered a custom saddle and worked with Charlie. He was knowledgable and professional throughout our long arduous process of getting the custom saddle made by the manufacurer. I would definately purchase a saddle from Horse Saddle Shop and Charlie again.

Karen Sieg

I have never been more pleased with a business and so satisfied with my purchase! I contacted Horse Saddle Shop about a saddle to fit my Haflinger. Josh spent a lot of time on phone and email with me until late night. I let him pick a bridle and breast plate to match. Everything was perfect, shipping was fast, boxed well, prices very fair. I love my saddle, and will definitely be making more purchases from Horse Saddle Shop.

Robyn Lebo from Facebook

Extremely good to deal with very helpful. I just can’t recommend these guys enough. Considering I am in Australia they were extremely good to deal with very helpful I recommend them 150% saddle was packed well and it’s beautiful very happy customer 5 start rating hands down.

Giustina Lee from Nevada

Incredibly streamlined and easy. I am absolutely blown away by the service horse saddle shop provided me. I am naturally a very indecisive person and incredibly picky when it comes to my gear, so after months of shopping and reading my boyfriend suggested here. He also had a positive experience. I browsed their wide selection of used saddles and there it was, MY saddle. The chat staff was incredibly helpful and my saddle was here 4 days later even with free shipping! The saddle was accurately represented in the photos is far from "used". I'm thrilled, to say the least. Thank you!

Tiffany Wilson from Facebook

After so much searching and being nervous about ordering a saddle online. I picked up the phone and called the Horse Saddle Shop to ask a few questions about a used saddle that was on their website. They were so nice and helpful. I ordered my very lightly used Circle Y saddle and a new saddle pad. It arrived very quickly. Only a few days. I LOVE my new saddle. In great condition and rides great! I would highly recommend using them for your tack needs. I know I will be in the future!

Ronda Trosper via Facebook

Customer service is amazing! Super quick shipping! My first saddle didn't fit correctly, they helped me find the right fit for both my horse and me, and we love our new Circle Y Kentucky gaited ❤ thank you Horse Saddle Shop!